Models of consulting vs organizational politics

If you have had an opportunity to observe organizational politics and a number of different settings in your work experience, I’d be interested in knowing your thoughts:

Which of the three change models (expert, doctor-patient; process consultation)do you think best reflects the reality of organizational politics based on your work experiences?

In the Army, the espoused value is to set aside politics for the needs of the organization in the nation, but the reality is that day-to-day operations are extremely political. It pains us when this fact is pointed out to us because of our espoused values of honor and professionalism. Our disdain for politics actually makes it much more difficult for us to engage in things like nation building and stability operations. Somehow it offends our sense of military professionalism to engage on a human level with civilians.

I try to remember that my mother was a civilian too, and that seems to help.

for this reason I think the positivist model acknowledges the sociology of organizations better than the other two, but I think it too easily offers an ideal world of cooperative human nature which can surprise the naïve consultant.

Related articles by Zemanta

• A military application of Appreciative Intelligence (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)
• My predictions for the future of business psychology (flowingmotion.wordpress.com)
• Noises off: Politics casts the die on theatre’s fate | Chris Wilkinson (guardian.co.uk)
• Organization Design 2 – Focus on Strategy (slideshare.net)
• Microsoft wades into politics with ‘TownHall’ social networking tech (techflash.com)
• 6 Steps in Enterprise 2.0 Governance Projects (rossdawsonblog.com)
• The Change-Management Challenge of Increasing IT Smarts (blogs.hbr.org)
• DAN RIEHL: Does the Tea Party Movement Need A Federation? “In my opinion, the existing loosely-con… (pajamasmedia.com)
• Summary and Review of Manufacturing The Employee: Management Knowledge From The 19th to 21st Centuries by Roy Jacques (bookstove.com)
• Models of consulting vs organizational politics (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)
• Army Enterprise Task Force: potentially greatest in-house management re-organization ever (usacac.army.mil)
• Learning from the process consultant (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)
• The persona of the process consultant: is it intentional or assigned? (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)
• Reflecting on self-directed leadership in a military college environment (an action research approach) (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)
• A reflection on leading and managing a complex Participatory Action Research curriculum project (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)
• The Problem of “Peace-gaming” (usacac.army.mil)
• Authenticity for “insiders” acting as change leaders (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)
• The simplicity of the Lewin change model (kansasreflections.wordpress.com)